Thinking About School Choice Long Term

Yesterday, Kristen Graham of the Philadelphia Inquirer posted a story entitled “Study finds high school choice ‘an illusion’.”

There is a pretty vibrant (and in some cases heated and profane) debate about this article happening in the Philadelphia Speaks Forum.  I am evaluating elementary school options for my kids, and I wrote about my own anxiety around sticking with the School District of Philadelphia with regards to the uncertainty of what comes after elementary school.  Here is the two sentence summary of that post:  If my family moves to the suburbs, we have a prescribed school path that we know will provide excellent schools for my kids.  If my family selects an elementary school in Philadelphia, we will just have to go through the process again for high school, possibly even for middle school, with no certainty of being satisfied with the options.

Ultimately this article doesn’t change my thought process much.  I am definitely in favor of school improvement, who isn’t?  I am disturbed by the inequality inherent in the Philadelphia school system, but right now I am most occupied by the priorities of my family.  I am concerned that my children won’t be able to get into their preferred school choice.

Graham reports that overall, about 70 percent of district eighth graders apply for admission to a school other than their local high school, but only 45 percent of them end up attending the special schools.  I am neither an expert or activist one way or another on school choice.  But it strikes me that if 45 percent of students who apply end up in magnet or lottery schools, that’s a pretty good number.  I would have expected the number to be lower, that the magnet capacity would not be able to accommodate so many.  In my opinion, the existence of magnet schools specific implies that only the best students can go.  Citywide lottery schools offer an additional degree of choice, but they have to have limited enrollment as well, by definition.  My sense would be that if you create more seats in magnet and citywide lottery schools, by definition you reduce the quality of all schools because of budget and the limited supply of quality teachers.  I guess that I could be wrong about that.

I attended a tour of a Philadelphia elementary school earlier this week, one that is generally considered to be among the better neighborhood (not charter) public schools in the city.  In attendance on the tour was a 4th grade student and parent considering entry for 5th grade.  Over the course of the tour, I learned (overheard) that the student currently attends The Philadelphia School, one of the elite private schools in Center City.  I have no more direct knowledge of their situation, but filling in the blanks, I jumped to the conclusion that the student was not accepted to Masterman for 5th grade.  Of course there could be a hundred other reasons that the family was considering this public school (the student didn’t like Masterman, finances didn’t allow for more private education, the student has special needs?), but my imagination ran wild.  How could a student at one of the top private schools in the city not get into Masterman?  I’m not even considering city private schools–how can I expect my child to get into a magnet coming out of a public school, even if it is one of the best in the city?  So, in an ironic twist–I loved the school on the tour, but I left also feeling more anxious about Philadelphia public schools than I did before.


4 Responses to “Thinking About School Choice Long Term”

  1. Julia Says:

    Before you jump to conclusions, my understanding is that Philly public school students have preference at Philly public schools like Masterman and other Special Application high schools. I may be wrong, but I think it’s actually harder to get in coming from a private school than it is coming from the public system.

  2. Len Lipkin Says:

    Thanks Julia. That would certainly make sense, though the Masterman website makes no mention of a preference for public school students. If anyone knows otherwise, I would certainly love to hear about it. The only comment about public versus private school students on the Masterman Admissions page says ” The national percentile on a nationally recognized standardized test will be considered when it is available, for non-public school students. Independent school students may submit ERB scores. ”

    Regardless, I acknowledge that I am jumping to many conclusions. Like I said, there could be a hundred reasons that the student was looking at Meredith coming from The Philadelphia School. I was simply talking about what went through my head at that moment.

  3. Rachel Margolin Says:

    Len- Maybe I am missing you point, but something else to consider…Just because a parent has enough money to pay for a top (or expensive) private school does not translate into a child having the intelligence to get into “a Masterman.” Bright children come from all soci-economic backgrounds. We can not buy our children success- and if we wanted to, there is no set formula for each child. (Mine might want to be a teacher, yours a doctor…who knows?)
    P.S. Interesting blog!

  4. Ranjith Says:

    Its make sometimes bored. So i think your school search view must be a short term process.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: